In "Goodfellas", who tells Tommy to "get his shine box"?
Answer
Billy Batts
Answer
Billy Batts
In "Goodfellas," Billy Batts tells Tommy to "get his shine box."
The insult occurs at a welcome-home celebration for Billy, who has just returned from prison. Billy remembers that Tommy once shined shoes and deliberately mocks him in front of their friends, including Jimmy Conway and Henry Hill. Tommy reacts angrily because he wants to be treated as a serious gangster rather than reminded of his former status.
The argument escalates after Billy continues provoking Tommy. Jimmy and Henry initially try to restrain the situation, but they eventually join Tommy in beating Billy. The group later hides his body, creating one of the film's defining episodes of sudden violence and criminal loyalty.
The line is sometimes misremembered as something Jimmy says, because Jimmy is central to the scene and helps control what happens afterward. Billy Batts is the speaker, while Tommy is the target of the remark.
Source: Wikipedia · fact-checked Aug. 2026