The podcast co-hosted by PJ Vogt and Alex Goldman that explored internet stories was Reply All.
The Gimlet Media show premiered on November 24, 2014, after Vogt and Goldman had previously worked together on WNYC’s technology-and-culture podcast TLDR. Reply All became known for explaining how people shape the internet—and how the internet shapes people—through reported stories, interviews, and investigations.
Its recurring segments included “Yes Yes No,” in which the hosts decoded confusing online posts, and “Super Tech Support,” which tackled strange or difficult technology problems. Emmanuel Dzotsi joined as a third host in 2020, but Vogt and Goldman remained the names most closely associated with the show’s original format.
A common mix-up is treating Reply All as a conventional technology-news podcast. It was broader: the program used internet-related mysteries to explore behavior, identity, culture, and institutions. The podcast released 189 episodes before its final installment in June 2022, following major changes to its hosting and production team.