Trenton tomato pie was created in which New Jersey city?

The story behind the answer

Trenton tomato pie was created in which New Jersey city? It was created in Trenton.

Trenton tomato pie is a circular, thin-crust pizza style that originated in Trenton, New Jersey. Its defining preparation reverses the usual topping order: cheese and other toppings go on the dough first, followed by tomato sauce spread over the top.

The style developed in the early 20th century within New Jersey’s Italian-American food culture. Joe’s Tomato Pie, now closed, opened in Trenton in 1910 and is generally identified as the first Trenton-style tomato-pie restaurant. Papa’s Tomato Pies followed in 1912 and remains one of the region’s historic names.

People often confuse Trenton tomato pie with the thicker, rectangular Italian tomato pie found elsewhere in New Jersey. Trenton’s version is commonly round, thin, and cheese-topped before the sauce. The Trenton area is also associated with De Lorenzo’s and Papa’s, two especially important names in the style’s continuing history.

Source: Wikipedia · fact-checked Sept. 2026

Add question to a list

Choose a list to keep this question in: