Who was the first person to be a repeat winner of the ALCS MVP Award?

The story behind the answer

Dave Stewart was the first person to win the American League Championship Series MVP Award twice. He won the award with the Oakland Athletics in 1990 and then with the Toronto Blue Jays in 1993.

Stewart's first ALCS MVP performance came during Oakland's four-game sweep of the Boston Red Sox in 1990. The right-handed starter won two games and posted a 1.13 earned-run average, helping the Athletics reach the World Series for the third consecutive year.

In 1993, Stewart was pitching for Toronto when the Blue Jays defeated the Chicago White Sox in six games. He again won two games, including the decisive sixth game, and became the first repeat winner of the ALCS honor. The Blue Jays went on to defeat Philadelphia in the World Series and repeat as champions.

The record is sometimes confused with the broader League Championship Series award. Three players have won an LCS MVP twice: Steve Garvey, Dave Stewart, and Orel Hershiser. Stewart was specifically the first to repeat in the American League Championship Series, making him the canonical answer to this question.

Source: Wikipedia · fact-checked Aug. 2026

Add question to a list

Choose a list to keep this question in: