Who directed John Indian to make a witch cake?
Answer
Mary Sibley
Answer
Mary Sibley
Mary Sibley directed John Indian to make a witch cake during the early Salem witchcraft crisis. Sibley was a church member and close neighbor of Reverend Samuel Parris, while John Indian was an enslaved man in the Parris household.
The ritual was intended to reveal or counteract the supposed witch responsible for the afflictions reported by the girls. According to accounts of the event, the cake was made from rye meal and liquid associated with the afflicted girls, then fed to a dog. The practice reflected English and New England folk beliefs about using a “witch cake” to identify a witch through the behavior of a bewitched animal.
Parris later condemned the act as a “grand error” and warned his congregation against seeking help from the Devil to fight the Devil. His church-record account says that Sibley directed the cake’s preparation and that the household’s troubles became more serious after the ritual.
The episode is sometimes confused with Tituba’s later confession because both women were connected to the witch-cake story. In the surviving account, however, Mary Sibley initiated the ritual and John Indian made the cake; Tituba was later pressured into confessing to witchcraft.
Source: Wikipedia · fact-checked Aug. 2026