What phrase did Carl Sagan popularize as a criterion for extraordinary claims?

The story behind the answer

Carl Sagan popularized the phrase “Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence” as a standard for evaluating remarkable assertions.

The wording became especially influential through Sagan’s 1979 book Broca’s Brain and his 1980 television series Cosmos. He used the principle to encourage skepticism toward claims about paranormal phenomena, extraterrestrial visitation, and other ideas that conflict with established evidence.

Sagan did not originate the underlying idea. Similar arguments appeared in the writings of David Hume, Pierre-Simon Laplace, and Thomas Jefferson. Skeptic Marcello Truzzi also used the closely related wording “extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof” in the 1970s. Sagan’s formulation became the best-known version.

The phrase does not mean unusual ideas should be rejected automatically. It means the evidence should be strong enough to justify overturning well-supported expectations. That nuance distinguishes it from “absence of evidence is not evidence of absence,” which addresses a different reasoning problem.

Source: Wikipedia · fact-checked Aug. 2026

Add question to a list

Choose a list to keep this question in: