What liquid was mixed with rye meal to make the witch cake?

The story behind the answer

Urine was mixed with rye meal to make the witch cake described in accounts of the Salem witch trials. The liquid was reportedly collected from the afflicted girls and combined with rye meal before the cake was prepared and fed to a dog.

The ritual was based on a folk belief that a witch cake could expose the person supposedly causing an illness or bewitchment. The dog’s reaction was expected to provide a clue about the invisible attacker. Rather than being a medical treatment, it was a form of sympathetic magic rooted in older European and colonial New England traditions.

The episode took place in the household of Reverend Samuel Parris during the early 1692 panic. Mary Sibley directed John Indian to make the cake, and Parris later denounced the act as an attempt to use the Devil’s help against the Devil. His account helped preserve the details of the unusual recipe.

Water, cider, and milk are plausible modern guesses because they are ordinary baking liquids, but they are not the liquid specified in the historical account. The unusual ingredient is precisely what makes this ritual memorable—and what shows how far the community had moved from ordinary explanations for the girls’ symptoms.

Source: Wikipedia · fact-checked Aug. 2026

Add question to a list

Choose a list to keep this question in: