In the first Halloween heist, what does Jake try to steal from Holt?

The story behind the answer

In the first Halloween heist, Jake tries to steal Holt’s Medal of Valor. The challenge begins when Jake boasts that Holt could not catch him if he were a criminal. Holt responds by daring Jake to take the medal from his office before midnight without being caught.

The Medal of Valor is secured inside a safe, making the theft more difficult than simply removing it from the wall. Jake attempts several schemes, including accessing Holt’s office and reproducing the captain’s fingerprint. After being arrested during one attempt, Jake reveals that he secretly recruited the entire squad by promising to complete their paperwork.

With help from Rosa, Terry, Amy, and Boyle, Jake ultimately opens the safe and wins the bet. The episode is the sixth episode of season 1, titled “Halloween,” and it established the annual Halloween Heist tradition. A common mix-up is the wrist watch, which becomes the target of the second Halloween heist, not the first.

Source: Wikipedia · fact-checked Aug. 2026

Add question to a list

Choose a list to keep this question in: